HKSI Paper 2 Market misconduct and improper trading practices question: s.307 bar the prosecution
Tribunal proceedings against Wendy Kwan for price rigging were instituted without the Secretary for Justice's consent under s.252A(1) of the SFO. The Department of Justice now wants to prosecute her under Part XIV for the same conduct. Does s.307 bar the prosecution?
- A No, because the s.307 bar does not apply to Tribunal proceedings instituted without that consent
- B No, but only if the Court of First Instance first declares the Tribunal proceedings void
- C Yes, until the Tribunal issues its report, after which the prosecution may proceed on the same facts
- D Yes, because Tribunal proceedings have been instituted for the same conduct and s.307 bars any later prosecution
Show the answer and explanation
Answer: A. No, because the s.307 bar does not apply to Tribunal proceedings instituted without that consent
Section 307(1) stops a Part XIV prosecution once Tribunal proceedings for the same conduct have been instituted, but s.307(2) says the bar does not apply to proceedings instituted under s.252 without the Secretary for Justice's consent. The consent requirement is what lets the Secretary for Justice choose the route.
Why not the others:
- Any Tribunal proceedings bar a prosecution: s.307(2) carves out proceedings started without consent.
- The bar lifts after the Tribunal reports: where s.307(1) applies, it continues after the report; it is not a timing rule.
- A court must first void the proceedings: s.307(2) works automatically; no court declaration is needed.
Rule: The s.307 bar on prosecution protects only Tribunal proceedings started with the Secretary for Justice's consent.
Source: Securities and Futures Ordinance (Cap. 571) s.252A(1), s.307(1)-(2) (as at November 2026).
Common mistake
Assuming any Tribunal case blocks prosecution. The bar is tied to the Secretary for Justice's consent, which is how the criminal route is protected.
Practise more Paper 2 Market misconduct and improper trading practices questions
Exam-style questions with worked answers, then full timed mocks. Free to start.
Related HKSI Paper 2 questions
Build a daily practice habit — a few exam-style questions a day, with worked answers. Free to start.
Start practising →Original study material mapped to the public HKSI Paper 2 syllabus. Unofficial, not endorsed by HKSI Institute or the SFC. Verify figures and rules against current guidance before relying on them.