HKSI Prep

HKSI Paper 16 Due diligence question: prospectus of Lam Tin Foods Ltd

HKSI Paper 16Due diligence

The prospectus of Lam Tin Foods Ltd, a Hong Kong company, omitted director Mr Ho's interest in a property the company is buying, a matter required by paragraph 19 of Schedule 3. Fellow director Ms Chan did not know of the interest. Is she liable for the omission?

  • A Yes, because each director is strictly liable for any Schedule 3 omission
  • B Not unless it is proved that she knew of the matter not disclosed
  • C Yes, unless she proves that she was not cognisant of the matter
  • D Not if the court finds the omitted interest immaterial, but otherwise yes
Show the answer and explanation

Answer: B. Not unless it is proved that she knew of the matter not disclosed

Section 38(4) lets a director escape liability for non-compliance by proving lack of knowledge or an honest mistake of fact, or where the court finds the matter immaterial or excusable. Its proviso goes further for paragraph 19 of Schedule 3 (directors' interests in the promotion or in property to be acquired): no director is liable for that omission unless it is proved that he or she knew of it.

Why not the others:

  • Liable unless she proves she was not cognisant: that is the general s.38(4)(a) defence; the proviso shifts the burden for paragraph 19.
  • Strictly liable: s.38(4) provides defences.
  • Liable unless immaterial: immateriality is only one route, and the proviso protects her anyway.

Rule: Paragraph 19 omissions: no liability without proof of knowledge (proviso to s.38(4)).

Source: Cap. 32 s.38(4) and proviso; Sch. 3 para 19 (as at November 2026).

Common mistake

Applying the general 'prove you did not know' defence. For paragraph 19 matters the claimant must prove the director knew.

Practise more Paper 16 Due diligence questions

Exam-style questions with worked answers, then full timed mocks. Free to start.

Start practising →

Related HKSI Paper 16 questions

Build a daily practice habit — a few exam-style questions a day, with worked answers. Free to start.

Start practising →

Original study material mapped to the public HKSI Paper 16 syllabus. Unofficial, not endorsed by HKSI Institute or the SFC. Verify figures and rules against current guidance before relying on them.