HKSI Paper 16 After prospectus issuance question: Sha Tin Logistics Ltd's compliance
Sha Tin Logistics Ltd's compliance adviser tells the board to announce that results will miss a listing-document profit forecast. The board, annoyed, wants to end the engagement. The adviser's work is of an acceptable standard and there is no fee dispute. May the issuer terminate it?
- A No; a compliance adviser cannot be removed for any reason until the end of the issuer's Fixed Period
- B Yes, if its board passes a resolution to that effect and the Exchange is told within 30 days of the termination
- C No; termination is allowed only for work of an unacceptable standard or a material fee dispute not resolved within 30 days
- D Yes, provided it appoints a replacement adviser within 3 months and announces the change as soon as practicable under Rule 3A.29
Show the answer and explanation
Answer: C. No; termination is allowed only for work of an unacceptable standard or a material fee dispute not resolved within 30 days
Rule 3A.26 lets a listed issuer terminate its compliance adviser only if the adviser's work is of an unacceptable standard or there is a material dispute over fees that cannot be resolved within 30 days. Disagreement with sound advice is neither ground. The rule protects the adviser's impartiality under Rule 3A.25.
Why not the others:
- Replace within 3 months and announce: those are the steps after a permitted termination (Rules 3A.27, 3A.29), not a ground for one.
- Board resolution and notice to the Exchange: no such route exists; the grounds in Rule 3A.26 are exhaustive.
- Never removable: Rule 3A.26 does allow termination on its two grounds.
Rule: Two grounds only: unacceptable work, or a material fee dispute unresolved within 30 days.
Source: Main Board Listing Rules r.3A.25, r.3A.26, r.3A.27, r.3A.29 (as at November 2026).
Common mistake
Confusing the replacement and announcement steps with the grounds for termination.
Practise more Paper 16 After prospectus issuance questions
Exam-style questions with worked answers, then full timed mocks. Free to start.
Related HKSI Paper 16 questions
Build a daily practice habit — a few exam-style questions a day, with worked answers. Free to start.
Start practising →Original study material mapped to the public HKSI Paper 16 syllabus. Unofficial, not endorsed by HKSI Institute or the SFC. Verify figures and rules against current guidance before relying on them.