HKSI Paper 15 Preparation for a listing application question: Cheung Sha Holdings offers to appoint Bayside Capital
Cheung Sha Holdings offers to appoint Bayside Capital as sponsor on terms that its fee is payable only if the listing completes. Bayside's Principal points out that paragraph 4.5 of the CFA Code only requires contingent fees to be disclosed to the regulators on request. May Bayside accept these terms?
- A Yes, provided Bayside discloses the contingent fee to the SFC and SEHK whenever they ask
- B Yes, provided the contingent fee is included in the total sponsor fees disclosed in the listing document
- C No, because the CFA Code prohibits every success-based fee for a corporate finance adviser in any deal
- D No; paragraph 17.11(b) bars "no deal; no fee" terms, and paragraph 17 prevails over the CFA Code
Show the answer and explanation
Answer: D. No; paragraph 17.11(b) bars "no deal; no fee" terms, and paragraph 17 prevails over the CFA Code
Paragraph 17.11(b)(ii) of the Code of Conduct requires the appointment to specify the fee terms and says no provision should be made for any "no deal; no fee" arrangement or one to that effect. Where the CFA Code and paragraph 17 conflict, paragraph 17 prevails for sponsors (Code of Conduct para 17.1(d); CFA Code para 1.5).
Why not the others:
- Disclosure on request: that is the CFA Code's general rule (para 4.5), overridden for sponsor fees.
- Disclosure in the listing document: App. D1A para 3A requires the total sponsor fee to be disclosed, but disclosure does not make a banned term acceptable.
- The CFA Code does not ban success fees; it requires disclosure on request.
Rule: Sponsor fees cannot depend on the deal completing, whatever the CFA Code allows other advisers.
Source: SFC Code of Conduct (December 2025 edition) paras 17.1(d), 17.11(b)(ii); Corporate Finance Adviser Code of Conduct paras 1.5, 4.5 (as at November 2026).
Common mistake
Applying the CFA Code's softer contingent-fee rule to a sponsor mandate.
Practise more Paper 15 Preparation for a listing application questions
Exam-style questions with worked answers, then full timed mocks. Free to start.
Related HKSI Paper 15 questions
Build a daily practice habit — a few exam-style questions a day, with worked answers. Free to start.
Start practising →Original study material mapped to the public HKSI Paper 15 syllabus. Unofficial, not endorsed by HKSI Institute or the SFC. Verify figures and rules against current guidance before relying on them.