HKSI Paper 15 General framework question: Board Rule 3A.05
Hollyhill Ltd's property valuer refuses to show Hollyhill's sponsor its draft valuation reports and the information it relied on, citing confidentiality terms in its engagement with Hollyhill. As the sponsor's Principal, what do you require under Main Board Rule 3A.05?
- A Hollyhill must amend the valuer's engagement terms so that every sponsor can access those drafts and that information
- B Access for the sponsor acting as primary channel of communication with SEHK only, not for any joint sponsor
- C Nothing more: the sponsor must rely on the final signed report, as an expert's drafts belong to the expert alone
- D Nothing directly: only the SFC can obtain an expert's drafts, by using its powers under s.179 of the SFO
Show the answer and explanation
Answer: A. Hollyhill must amend the valuer's engagement terms so that every sponsor can access those drafts and that information
Rule 3A.05(4) requires the sponsor's engagement agreement to oblige the applicant to give the sponsor access to all relevant records, and in particular to ensure that experts' terms of engagement entitle every sponsor to access the expert, its reports and draft reports, its terms of engagement and the information given to or relied on by it. Under r.3A.05(7) the applicant must procure supplements to experts' engagement letters where needed.
Why not the others:
- Final report only: drafts and underlying information are expressly covered.
- Only the SFC: the access right is built into the engagement terms; s.179 is a separate investigative power.
- Primary-channel sponsor only: the rule says every sponsor.
Rule: The applicant must open its experts, including drafts and underlying information, to every sponsor.
Source: Main Board Listing Rules r.3A.05(4), (7) (as at November 2026).
Common mistake
Accepting an expert's confidentiality terms. The applicant must rewrite them to give every sponsor access.
Practise more Paper 15 General framework questions
Exam-style questions with worked answers, then full timed mocks. Free to start.
Related HKSI Paper 15 questions
Build a daily practice habit — a few exam-style questions a day, with worked answers. Free to start.
Start practising →Original study material mapped to the public HKSI Paper 15 syllabus. Unofficial, not endorsed by HKSI Institute or the SFC. Verify figures and rules against current guidance before relying on them.