HKSI Prep

HKSI Paper 2 Regulatory framework question: Kwok sues Lion Peak Securities Ltd in the District Court for damages

HKSI Paper 2Regulatory framework

Ms Kwok sues Lion Peak Securities Ltd in the District Court for damages. Her only ground is that the firm did not follow a provision of an SFC guideline published under s.399 of the SFO; she alleges no breach of contract, tort or statutory duty. How does s.399 bear on her claim?

  • A The failure does not by itself make the firm liable to judicial proceedings, so a claim resting only on the guideline fails
  • B Her claim can succeed, but only if the SFC has first disciplined the firm for the same failure under Part IX of the SFO
  • C The guideline is subsidiary legislation, so its breach gives her a statutory right to damages against the firm
  • D The guideline is not law, so no court may admit it in evidence in any proceedings, including those under the SFO
Show the answer and explanation

Answer: A. The failure does not by itself make the firm liable to judicial proceedings, so a claim resting only on the guideline fails

Section 399(6) of the SFO says failure to comply with a code or guideline does not by itself render a person liable to any judicial or other proceedings. Because her claim rests on the guideline alone, it fails. In proceedings under the SFO the guideline is admissible and, if relevant, taken into account.

Why not the others:

  • Subsidiary legislation: s.399(8) says a code or guideline under s.399 is not subsidiary legislation.
  • Prior SFC discipline: nothing in s.399 makes a civil claim depend on SFC action.
  • Inadmissible in any court: s.399(6) expressly admits it in proceedings under the SFO.

Rule: Breaching an SFC code or guideline is not by itself actionable, but courts in SFO proceedings take it into account.

Source: Securities and Futures Ordinance (Cap. 571) s.399(6), (8) (as at November 2026).

Common mistake

Treating SFC guidelines as law with a private right of action. They carry weight in SFO proceedings and on fitness and properness, not as a cause of action.

Practise more Paper 2 Regulatory framework questions

Exam-style questions with worked answers, then full timed mocks. Free to start.

Start practising →

Related HKSI Paper 2 questions

Build a daily practice habit — a few exam-style questions a day, with worked answers. Free to start.

Start practising →

Original study material mapped to the public HKSI Paper 2 syllabus. Unofficial, not endorsed by HKSI Institute or the SFC. Verify figures and rules against current guidance before relying on them.