HKSI Prep
← All study notes

LE Paper 15 · Topic 5

Due diligence: the prospectus, the sponsor's inquiries, experts and the MD&A

Due diligence is how a sponsor earns the right to tell the Exchange and investors that a listing document is true, accurate and complete in all material respects. This topic starts with the laws that set what a listing document-cum-prospectus must contain and how it is registered (Cap. 32, Chapter 11 and Appendix D1A), then the rules on how due diligence is done (Code of Conduct paragraphs 17.4 and 17.6, Practice Note 21, Appendix E1), the duties of the applicant and the parties around it (rule 3A.05), and the planning, interviews and site visits that make up the exercise. It goes on to professional scepticism, verification, experts and other third parties (paragraph 17.7) and the MD&A (paragraph 17.8). Questions turn on who must believe what, by when, and to which standard.

30 min read14 sections

Checked as at 14 November 2026: e-Legislation, Companies (Winding Up and Miscellaneous Provisions) Ordinance (Cap. 32) ss.37, 38, 38D, 40, 40A, 342, 342C and Sch. 3; Securities and Futures Ordinance (Cap. 571) s.108. SFC: Code of Conduct for Persons Licensed by or Registered with the SFC (December 2025 edition) paras 17.1-17.6, 17.10; Report on the Thematic Review of Licensed Corporations Engaged in Sponsor Business (March 2018). HKEX Main Board Listing Rules rr.3A.02-3A.12, 9.03, 9.10A, 9.11, Chapters 11 and 11A, Appendices D1A and E1, Practice Note 21. Checked as at 14 November 2026: SFC Code of Conduct for Persons Licensed by or Registered with the SFC (December 2025 edition, published January 2026) paras 17.5-17.8, 17.10, 17.15; SFC Report on the Thematic Review of Licensed Corporations Engaged in Sponsor Business (March 2018); SFC circular to licensed corporations carrying out sponsor work (30 January 2026) and appendix. HKEX Main Board Listing Rules r.3A.11-3A.12, Practice Note 21, Appendix D1A paras 32, 34, 36, Appendix E1; HKEX Guide for New Listing Applicants (July 2026) chapters 3.1, 3.4, 3.11. Independent prep, not endorsed by HKSI Institute or the SFC.

Must-know for the exam

  • Prospectus content: s.38 and Sch. 3 for Hong Kong companies, s.342 for overseas ones; registration under s.38D or s.342C. For listed shares the Exchange authorises registration (rules 11A.03-11A.04).
  • Listing documents contain every Appendix D1A item plus whatever investors need for an informed assessment (rules 11.06-11.07); every director, including named proposed directors, accepts responsibility (rule 11.12).
  • Non-expert sections: the sponsor needs reasonable grounds to believe, and must believe, they are true, accurate and complete in all material respects (Code of Conduct para 17.5(b); Appendix E1(g)).
On this page · 14 sections

Cap. 32: prospectus contents and registration

A listing document that offers shares to the public is also a prospectus under the Companies (Winding Up and Miscellaneous Provisions) Ordinance (Cap. 32), so it must satisfy both Cap. 32 and the Listing Rules; compliance with one does not guarantee compliance with the other (rules 11.01, 11A.01). Which Cap. 32 sections apply depends on where the issuer is incorporated, not where the offer is made.

PointHong Kong companyCompany incorporated outside Hong Kong
Contentss.38(1): the matters in Part I and the reports in Part II of Schedule 3s.342(1): the same Schedule 3 matters and reports, plus particulars of its constitution and incorporation
LanguageEnglish with a Chinese translation, or Chinese with an English translation (s.38(1))The same (s.342(1)(b))
DatingDated; the date is taken as the publication date (s.37)Dated, with the same presumption (s.342(1))
RegistrationRegistration authorised, and a copy registered by the Registrar, on or before publication (s.38D(1))Registration authorised, and a copy registered, before it is issued, circulated or distributed in Hong Kong (s.342C(1))
  • •Schedule 3 para 3: sufficient particulars to let a reasonable person form a valid and justifiable opinion of the shares and of the company's financial condition and profitability.
  • •Schedule 3 para 17: every material contract made within the 2 years before issue, other than in the ordinary course of business.
  • •Schedule 3 para 19: each director's interest in the promotion of, or in property to be acquired by, the company.
  • •Schedule 3 Part II para 31: an auditors' report on profits and losses for each of the 3 financial years before issue.

Who authorises registration. For a prospectus relating to shares approved for listing, the SFC's functions under ss.38D(3) and (5) and 342C(3) and (5) were transferred to the Exchange by a transfer order under s.25 of the SFO (rules 11A.03-11A.04). The Exchange vets the prospectus and issues a certificate authorising registration; the issuer delivers it to the Companies Registry and the Registrar registers it (rule 11A.08). The SFC keeps the power to grant certificates of exemption (rule 11A.06). The Exchange's certificate is neither confirmation of Cap. 32 compliance nor registration (note to rule 11A.10).

Void conditions and defences. A condition making an applicant waive compliance with s.38, or fixing him with notice of documents not referred to in the prospectus, is void (s.38(2)). A director avoids liability for non-compliance by proving he did not know of the matter or made an honest mistake of fact, or where the court finds it immaterial or excusable (s.38(4)). For paragraph 19 matters no one is liable unless it is proved he knew (proviso to s.38(4)).

Trap: following the place of the offer instead of the place of incorporation, and thinking the Exchange registers the prospectus. It authorises registration; the Registrar registers.

Takeaway: Hong Kong company: ss.38 and 38D. Overseas company: ss.342 and 342C. Listed shares: the Exchange authorises, the Registrar registers.

Practise this section · 2 questions (free account) →

Listing Rules: Chapter 11 and Appendix D1A

Rule 11.06 requires the listing document of an issuer with no listed shares to contain every item in Appendix D1A. Over all of them sits the overriding principle in rule 11.07: the particulars needed for an investor to make an informed assessment of the issuer's activities, assets and liabilities, financial position, management and prospects, its profits and losses, and the rights attaching to the securities. The Exchange may require more, or allow items to be omitted or modified (rule 11.11).

RequirementSource
Responsibility statement: each director, including any proposed director named, accepts responsibility; the directors confirm, after all reasonable enquiries, that the document is accurate and complete in all material respects and not misleading or deceptiver.11.12; App. D1A para 2
English, accompanied by a Chinese translationr.11.14
HKEX and Exchange disclaimer on the front or inside front coverr.11.20
Total fees paid or payable to the sponsorApp. D1A para 3A
Working capital sufficient for at least 12 months from publication (Chapter 18A and pre-commercial Chapter 18C issuers: at least 125% of costs for 12 months; mineral companies: 125% of present requirements)App. D1A para 36 and Notes 1, 2, 4
Material adverse change since the end of the period in the accountants' report, or a negative statementApp. D1A para 38
Litigation or claims of material importance, or a negative statementApp. D1A para 40
Intended use of proceedsApp. D1A para 48
Material contracts made in the 2 years before issue, other than in the ordinary course of businessApp. D1A para 52
  • •Profit forecasts: no reference to future profits without a formal forecast (r.11.16). The issuer decides in advance, with its sponsor, whether to include one; the reporting accountants report on accounting policies and calculations, and the sponsor reports that the directors made it after due and careful enquiry (r.11.17).
  • •The forecast period should normally end at the financial year-end; exceptionally at a half-year end, with an undertaking to audit the interim report; no other period is allowed (r.11.18). Assumptions must be specific, not general (r.11.19).
  • •Illustrations are allowed if they are not misleading in form and context (r.11.15).
  • •After issue and before dealings, a significant change or significant new matter needs a supplementary listing document, submitted to the Exchange as soon as practicable and issued once it has no further comments (r.11.13).

Trap: applying the ordinary 12-month working capital test to a Chapter 18A biotech applicant, or forgetting that a significant change before dealings needs a supplementary listing document.

Takeaway: Appendix D1A lists the items; rule 11.07 demands whatever else investors need; every director answers for the whole document.

Practise this section · 4 questions (free account) →

The standard: true, accurate and complete in all material respects

The same phrase runs through the rules: information must be true, accurate and complete in all material respects and not misleading or deceptive. Materiality is the test: not every trivial detail, but nothing a reasonable investor would need.

WhoWhat they must ensure or believeSource
Applicant and each directorThe Application Proof is accurate and complete in all material respects and not misleading or deceptiver.9.03(3A)(a)
DirectorsResponsibility statement: after all reasonable enquiries, the listing document is accurate and complete in all material respects and nothing is omitted that would make it misleadingApp. D1A para 2
Sponsor, throughoutReasonable endeavours that everything given to the Exchange and the SFC is true, accurate, complete and not misleading in all material respects; promptly report anything that casts doubt on itApp. E1(b)
Sponsor, at issue: non-expert sectionsReasonable grounds to believe, and does believe, they are true, accurate and complete in all material respects, not misleading or deceptive, with no misleading omissionCode of Conduct para 17.5(b); App. E1(g)(iii)
Sponsor, at issue: opinions and forward-looking statementsMade after due and careful consideration on bases and assumptions that are fair and reasonableApp. E1(g)(iii)(B)
Sponsor, at issue: expert reportsAs a non-expert, no reasonable grounds to believe they are untrue, misleading or contain material omissions (covered under experts)Code of Conduct para 17.5(c); App. E1(i)

Overall, at issue the sponsor must have reasonable grounds to believe, and believe, that the document contains sufficient particulars for a reasonable person to form a valid and justifiable opinion of the shares and the applicant's financial condition and profitability (Code of Conduct para 17.5(a); App. E1(g)(ii)), echoing Schedule 3 para 3 of Cap. 32.

Trap: using the expert-report test (no reasonable grounds to believe untrue) for the non-expert sections, or testing a directors' forecast as if it were a verifiable fact.

Takeaway: Non-expert facts: positive belief in material truth. Opinions: careful and fairly based. Expert reports: no reason to doubt.

Practise this section · 2 questions (free account) →

What due diligence is and why it matters

A sponsor's primary role is to give the Exchange and the market assurance that the applicant complies with the Listing Rules and other legal and regulatory requirements, and that the listing document gives investors enough to form a valid and justifiable opinion of the shares, financial condition and profitability; it also advises and guides the applicant (Code of Conduct para 17.1(b)). Due diligence is the reasonable inquiry that supports that assurance (Practice Note 21 para 1).

Paragraph 17.6(a): a sponsor conducts due diligence to gain a thorough knowledge and understanding of the applicant and to satisfy itself about the disclosure. It must use reasonable judgement on the nature and extent of the work, which varies from case to case; there is no exhaustive list of steps. Practice Note 21 para 3 and Code of Conduct para 17.6(h) say the work may be considerably more extensive than PN21's typical examples.

LiabilityWhoDefence that only inquiry can supply
Civil: compensation to subscribers for loss from an untrue statement (Cap. 32 s.40)Directors at issue; persons named with their authority as directors or proposed directors; promoters (not professionals acting as such); persons who authorised the issue (not the SFC or the Exchange)Reasonable ground to believe, and did believe up to allotment, that the statement was true (s.40(2)(d)); or withdrawal with public notice
Criminal: imprisonment and a fine (Cap. 32 s.40A)Any person who authorised the issueThe statement was immaterial, or reasonable grounds to believe and belief up to issue that it was true
Civil: misrepresentation inducing a subscription (SFO s.108)The maker of a fraudulent, reckless or negligent misrepresentation; directors presumed to have made a company'sNot available where Cap. 32 s.40 applies (s.108(4))

The SFC's 2018 thematic review of sponsors found box-ticking: standard checklists followed without adapting them to the applicant, and obvious red flags not followed up (Cases A to F).

Trap: treating ignorance as a defence. Every route asks whether a belief rested on reasonable grounds, and only inquiry gives grounds.

Takeaway: Due diligence gives the sponsor, and everyone behind the prospectus, reasonable grounds for belief. Tailor it; never just tick a checklist.

Practise this section · 3 questions (free account) →

The rules on due diligence: paras 17.4 and 17.6, Practice Note 21, Appendix E1

Three layers apply together. The SFC's Code of Conduct paragraph 17 (the SFC Sponsor Provisions) sets the standard; it prevails over the Listing Rules, the Sponsor Guidelines and the CFA Code if they conflict (para 17.1(d)). The Exchange's rule 3A.11 requires the sponsor to be closely involved in preparing the listing document and to discharge Appendix E1; rule 3A.12 requires it to have regard to Practice Note 21 and the SFC Sponsor Provisions. Where PN21 and the SFC provisions overlap, the more onerous one prevails (PN21 para 1A).

WhenWhat the sponsor must have done or believeSource
Before submitting the applicationAll reasonable due diligence done (except matters that can only be dealt with later) and all resulting material information in the Application Proof; Application Proof substantially completeCode of Conduct para 17.4(a)-(b)
Before submitting the applicationReasonable opinion that Chapter 8 is met (except waivers applied for in writing); systems let the applicant comply and let directors assess its financial position and prospects; directors competent collectively, and individually for their own rolesCode of Conduct para 17.4(c)
On submissionAll material issues known to it that bear on suitability or the public interest disclosed in writing to the ExchangeCode of Conduct para 17.4(d)
On or before issue of the listing documentReasonable grounds to believe, and belief, on Chapter 8 compliance (except as waived), sufficiency, the non-expert sections, systems, directors' competence and other material issuesApp. E1(g); Code of Conduct para 17.5
After issue, before dealingsDeclaration in Form E lodged with the ExchangeApp. E1(d); rr.9.10A(7), 9.11(36)
  • •Paragraph 17.6(d): in preparing the listing document the sponsor oversees and is closely involved in it; understands the applicant, its industry and competitors; examines the directors' integrity and competence and the reliability of the financial information; assesses performance, prospects, legality and material changes since the last audited balance sheet; and independently verifies all material information.
  • •Appendix E1 also requires the sponsor to cooperate with the Exchange and the SFC and accompany the applicant to meetings with the Exchange unless asked not to (E1(c)), report material non-compliance as soon as practicable, even after it stops acting if it learned of it while acting (E1(e)), and report its reasons for ceasing to act (E1(f)).
1. By when must all reasonable due diligence be complete?

Before the listing application is submitted, except matters that by their nature can only be dealt with later (para 17.4(a)).

2. When must the sponsor hold its belief about the non-expert sections?

At the time the listing document is issued (para 17.5(b); App. E1(g)).

3. When is the sponsor's Form E declaration lodged?

After the listing document is issued and before dealings begin (App. E1(d)).

4. PN21 and paragraph 17 both cover a step but set different standards. Which applies?

The more onerous one (PN21 para 1A).

Trap: mixing up the timing points: due diligence complete at submission (para 17.4), beliefs held at issue (para 17.5, App. E1(g)), Form E before dealings (App. E1(d)).

Takeaway: Code of Conduct sets the standard, PN21 gives typical steps, Appendix E1 lists the beliefs. Submission, issue, dealings: know what is due when.

Practise this section · 5 questions (free account) →

Roles of the listing applicant and third parties (rule 3A.05)

Rule 3A.05: a new applicant and its directors must assist the sponsor and must ensure that its substantial shareholders and associates also assist. The written engagement agreement under rule 3A.02 must contain at least these obligations of the applicant and its directors:

  • •(1) fully assist the sponsor's due diligence;
  • •(2) procure all relevant parties engaged for the listing application (financial advisers, experts and other third parties) to cooperate fully with the sponsor;
  • •(3) give each sponsor every assistance to provide information to the regulators, including notifying them of the reasons when a sponsor ceases to act;
  • •(4) give access to all relevant records; experts' engagement terms, whether or not for an expert section, must entitle every sponsor to access the expert, its reports and drafts (written and oral), its terms of engagement, the information it relied on, and its correspondence with the applicant and the regulators, with free copies;
  • •(5) keep the sponsor informed of material changes to information given or accessed;
  • •(6) provide or procure all necessary consents; and
  • •(7) procure supplements to experts' engagement letters where needed to comply with (4).
Third partyTypical due diligence role
Legal advisersVerifying title to properties; reviewing current legal proceedings (Code of Conduct para 17.6(g); PN21 para 5)
Reporting accountantsThe accountants' report; may also review internal controls; comfort on agreed procedures (para 17.6(g) and footnote 7; PN21 para 12(b))
Industry or market consultantsMarket research on the industry and competitors
Investigative agenciesBackground and other investigative checks
Valuers and other expertsValuations and independent inspection where the sponsor cannot assess an asset itself (PN21 para 13(e) Note 2)

The applicant and its directors also confirm in writing that financial information not reported on by the reporting accountants has been properly extracted from the underlying accounting records, after due and careful inquiry (PN21 para 13(a)). Where the sponsor finds the applicant's procedures, directors or key managers inadequate, it discusses this with the board, recommends remedial steps such as training, and typically ensures they are taken before listing (PN21 para 16). A sponsor cannot abrogate responsibility for due diligence to any third party it engages (para 17.6(g)); how far it may rely on their work is covered under experts and other third parties.

Trap: thinking substantial shareholders are outside the rules, or that only the lead sponsor gets access to experts. The applicant answers for both.

Takeaway: The applicant, its directors and their substantial shareholders must open every door; every sponsor gets full access to experts and drafts.

Practise this section · 3 questions (free account) →

Planning and recording the due diligence exercise

Practice Note 21 para 4 expects a sponsor to document its due diligence planning and significant deviations from it, showing it turned its mind to what inquiries were necessary and reasonably practicable, and to document its conclusions on the applicant's compliance with all Chapter 8 conditions, taking waivers into account.

Record kept for each listing assignmentCode of Conduct para
A due diligence plan identifying the time and skill sets of the people needed to carry it out17.10(c)(ii)(A)
Changes to the plan and the reasons17.10(c)(ii)(B)
The nature, timing and extent of due diligence procedures17.10(c)(ii)(C)
The results of due diligence with the sponsor's assessment of them17.10(c)(ii)(D)
The bases for its opinions and conclusions, and all significant matters arising, whether or not disclosed in the final listing document17.10(c)(iv)-(v)
Retention: a complete set kept in Hong Kong for at least 7 years after completion or termination17.10(d)
  • •Typical PN21 inquiry areas: the directors' experience, competence and integrity, including the track record of other listed companies they have served (para 11); compliance with the qualifications for listing (para 12); the business, finances, assets, contracts, disputes, industry and the listing document (para 13); expert sections (para 14); accounting and management systems and the directors' understanding of their obligations (para 15).
  • •Good practice from the SFC's 2018 thematic review: keep background research updated during a long process or in a fast-changing industry; have senior Transaction Team members approve customised plans; log every material issue with a due diligence note.
  • •Timing: interviewing stakeholders on the day of submission leaves no time to resolve what they raise (thematic review, Case G).

Trap: treating the plan as fixed or as something the regulator approves. The sponsor owns it, adapts it, and records each significant change and why.

Takeaway: Plan for this applicant, record every change and reason, finish before submission, and keep the file in Hong Kong for 7 years.

Practise this section · 3 questions (free account) →

Interviews, site visits, documents and red flags

Paragraph 17.6(e) lists the independent steps: (i) inquire directly of knowledgeable persons inside or outside the applicant (directors, key staff, consultants, controlling shareholders); (ii) inspect key physical assets, including production facilities where appropriate; (iii) interview major business stakeholders such as customers, suppliers, creditors and bankers; (iv) on material matters, review underlying records and supporting documents; (v) on material matters, obtain information from outside the applicant, such as public filings, databases, external confirmations, third-party data on competitors and external agents' checks.

Interview requirement (para 17.6(f))What it rules out
Select interviewees independently on objective and proportionate criteria, such as high-value transactions or unusual characteristicsInterviewing whoever the applicant puts forward
Interview directly, with minimal involvement of the applicantApplicant staff hosting, joining or arranging the calls
Confirm the interviewee's bona fides: identity, authority and knowledgePhone numbers and identities taken only from the applicant
Hold an in-depth discussion and follow up incomplete or unsatisfactory answersUnanswered questions left open
Identify irregularities (an interview away from the registered or business address, a reluctant interviewee) and get them explained and resolvedRelying on an irregular interview as if it were normal
Keep records that are reasonably accurate, complete and reliable in all material respectsUndocumented or unverifiable notes
  • •Good interview practice (thematic review): meet at the interviewee's premises; cross-check more than one proof of identity, such as a business card plus an identity or staff card; for calls, ring the company's general line taken from a reliable public source; ask for call notes to be validated by the interviewee's company.
  • •Site visits: PN21 para 13(e) expects physical inspection of material assets, owned or leased, including property, plant, equipment, inventory and biological assets such as livestock or crops. The sponsor visits to assess extent, quality, quantity and use (Note 1). If it genuinely cannot assess an asset without an expert, for example because it suspects the asset is smaller than represented, it ensures the applicant instructs a qualified independent expert, who gives a written report (Note 2).
  • •Documents: financial statements of the applicant and material subsidiaries, internal financial records, tax certificates and supporting documents for the trading record period (PN21 para 12(b)); the business aspects of material contracts (para 13(h)); legal proceedings current or recently resolved, for example in the previous 12 months (para 13(i)); title documents for material assets (para 13(l)).
  • •Red flags the SFC found ignored: invoices that did not reconcile with payments; third parties heavily involved in shipping and settlement; customers whose own recorded trade was smaller than their reported purchases from the applicant; interviewee lists drawn from applicant summaries that did not match its raw system data (thematic review, Cases A, C, E). Each needs further inquiry until resolved.

Trap: accepting the applicant's arrangements for interviews and site visits. Independence is the point: the sponsor chooses, contacts, checks and follows up itself.

Takeaway: Pick interviewees yourself, confirm who they are, visit material assets, read the source documents, and chase every red flag to the end.

Practise this section · 3 questions (free account) →

Professional scepticism

Code of Conduct paragraph 17.6(b) and Practice Note 21 (PN21) paragraph 2 use the same words. A sponsor should examine with professional scepticism the accuracy and completeness of statements, representations and other information given to it by the listing applicant or its directors. Professional scepticism means making a critical assessment with a questioning mind and being alert to information, including information from experts, that contradicts or brings into question the reliability of those statements.

It is a questioning attitude to evidence, not a presumption that the directors are dishonest. It runs through the whole engagement and covers experts' work too: an expert's finding that conflicts with what management says is exactly the kind of information the sponsor must be alert to.

The SFC's Report on the Thematic Review of Licensed Corporations Engaged in Sponsor Business (March 2018) found sponsors that did not follow up obvious red flags:

  • •Recorded sales to customers larger than those customers' own sales and purchases in local government figures, with no follow-up (Case C).
  • •Inconsistent and backdated documents behind a claim that the controlling shareholder held a supplier's shares only on trust; the sponsor relied on his statutory declaration and the applicant's confirmation (Case B).
  • •Customers paying through opaque third parties in other countries; the sponsor relied on a legal opinion that the practice was lawful and on the reporting accountants raising no concerns, without asking whether the sales were genuine (Case D).
  • •Interviewees chosen from a management summary table that did not match the applicant's own system data (Case E).

Trap: treating a document from the applicant, a statutory declaration or an expert's answer to a narrower question as closing a red flag. Scepticism asks what the red flag actually puts in doubt and tests that.

Takeaway: Questioning mind, alert to contradictions from any source, including experts. A red flag needs evidence that answers it, not a confirmation.

Practise this section · 5 questions (free account) →

Verification and the listing document

Code of Conduct paragraph 17.6(c): a sponsor should not merely accept statements, representations and documents from the listing applicant or its directors at face value. Depending on the nature and source of the information and the context, it should perform appropriate verification procedures, such as reviewing source documents, inquiring of knowledgeable persons or obtaining independently sourced information. Where circumstances cast doubt on information or point to a potential problem, it should do additional due diligence. Over-reliance on management's representations or confirmations cannot be regarded as reasonable due diligence.

Verification is how due diligence reaches the listing document. In preparing it, paragraph 17.6(d) requires the sponsor, among other things, to oversee and be closely involved in its preparation and to undertake independent verification of all material information, including documents, statements and representations from the applicant and its directors. Main Board Listing Rule 3A.11(1) also requires the sponsor to be closely involved in preparing the listing documents.

Claim in the draftWeak on its ownVerification that tests it
Sales to a major customerManagement's summary table or a finance director's confirmationInvoices matched to payments and shipping records; direct contact with the customer; independent data on the customer
Number of shops or plantsA figure in a management presentationLeases, business licences, site visits
An exclusive distribution agreementThe chief executive's written confirmationThe signed agreement, confirmation from the counterparty, records of trading under it

PN21 paragraph 13(a) adds a specific step for financial information not reported on by the reporting accountants: a written confirmation from the applicant and its directors that it was properly extracted from the underlying accounting records, and the sponsor being satisfied that the confirmation was given after due and careful inquiry.

The SFC's circular to sponsors of 30 January 2026 reported over-reliance on legal advisers, accountants and others, including for drafting the listing document, without adequate assessment of their competency and resources.

Trap: thinking a disclaimer can replace checking. HKEX's Guide allows cautionary language for official government statistics (and for practical difficulties in verifying research reports), not for the applicant's own claims.

Takeaway: All material information is verified independently, by a method suited to its source. The sponsor stays closely involved in drafting the listing document.

Practise this section · 4 questions (free account) →

Relying on third parties' due diligence work

Code of Conduct paragraph 17.6(g): a sponsor cannot abrogate responsibility for due diligence. Where it engages a third party for specific due diligence tasks (lawyers verifying title to properties, accountants reviewing internal controls, consultants doing market research, agencies doing investigative work), the sponsor remains responsible for the matters those tasks relate to. A third party's work, in itself, is not sufficient evidence that the sponsor has done reasonable due diligence. How far the work can be relied on may depend on the third party's professional qualifications.

Minimum steps (para 17.6(g))What it means
Qualified and competent?Assess whether the third party is appropriately qualified and competent for the tasks
ScopeConsider the scope and extent of the tasks
Own opinion on resultsAssess the results and decide whether they are a sufficient basis, or whether further due diligence is needed
ConsistencyAssess whether the results are consistent with other information the sponsor knows, including from its own work
Use of resultsAssess whether the results should go into the listing document and whether they should be brought to the regulators' attention

PN21 paragraph 5 says the same for third-party professionals (for example, reviewing current legal proceedings): the sponsor must be satisfied it is reasonable to rely on them, including as to their competence, scope of work and methodology, and that their report is consistent with what the sponsor knows about the applicant.

One firm, two roles: if an accounting firm reviews internal controls and is also the reporting accountant, paragraph 17.6(g) governs reliance on the internal controls review and paragraph 17.7 governs its work as reporting accountant (footnote to para 17.6(g)). Records: for due diligence done by third parties, the sponsor keeps information on the paragraph 17.6(g) matters (para 17.10(c)).

Trap: believing that delegating a task delegates the responsibility, or that the third party's report is the evidence. The sponsor needs its own assessment of the third party and the results.

Takeaway: Delegate the task, never the responsibility. Check competence and scope, test results against what you know, record your assessment.

Practise this section · 5 questions (free account) →

Expert reports: the non-expert sponsor's checks

Two standards apply at the time of issue of the listing document (Code of Conduct para 17.5(b)-(c)):

Part of the listing documentWhat the sponsor must believe
Non-expert sectionsAfter reasonable due diligence, reasonable grounds to believe, and belief, that the information is true, accurate and complete in all material respects and not misleading
Expert reportsAs a non-expert, after the paragraph 17.7 due diligence, no reasonable grounds to believe, and no belief, that the information is untrue, misleading or has material omissions

Paragraph 17.7 sets the due diligence on expert reports:

  • •(a) Satisfy itself that the expert is appropriately qualified, experienced and competent to give the opinion; sufficiently resourced; and independent of the listing applicant, its directors and controlling shareholder(s).
  • •(b) Assess whether the expert's scope of work is appropriate to the opinion and adequately covers the reliability of information given to the expert. If not: ask for the scope to be expanded, seek a third party's help, or extend its own due diligence using paragraph 17.6 procedures.
  • •Note 1: a reporting accountant performs audit procedures under professional standards, so the sponsor is not expected to do further due diligence on that information, unless it is aware of matters raising concerns, which it must then follow up.
  • •Note 2: where an expert relies on a third party's work (for example, lawyers confirming title for a valuer), the sponsor follows paragraph 17.6(g); if the expert itself follows standards at least equivalent to paragraph 17.6(g), the sponsor may rely on the expert's work on that point.
  • •(c) Assess whether the material bases and assumptions (for financial information, critical accounting policies and estimates) are fair, reasonable and complete.
  • •(d) Critically review the opinion against everything else it knows; corroborate the report with the non-expert sections; follow up and resolve material discrepancies.
  • •(e) Each step is done to the standard expected of a sponsor that is not itself expert in the matter.

PN21 paragraph 14 lists typical steps: interview the expert, review its terms of engagement and any scope limitations, check the disclosure of facts, assumptions and scope, and disclose any qualification of the opinion. Where no professional body sets an independence standard, obtain the expert's written confirmation of independence and be satisfied there is no cause to inquire further. Appendix E1 para (h) adds that where an expert does not verify factual information it relies on, the sponsor must believe that information is true in all material respects.

Trap: assuming an expert's name on a report ends the sponsor's work. The sponsor checks the expert and corroborates the report; it only escapes re-doing the audit itself.

Takeaway: Qualified, resourced, independent; right scope; fair assumptions; corroborated with the rest of the document. Judged as a non-expert would.

Practise this section · 5 questions (free account) →

Who counts as an expert; industry and government data

Code of Conduct paragraph 17.15 defines the terms that decide which standard applies:

  • •Expert: includes an accountant, engineer, appraiser and any other person whose profession gives authority to a statement made by him (para 17.15(c)).
  • •Expert report: any part of the listing document made on an expert's authority, or a copy of or extract from an expert's report, opinion, statement or valuation, where the expert consents to its inclusion and the listing document states that consent has been given and not withdrawn (para 17.15(d)).
  • •Non-expert sections: every part of the listing document that is not part of an expert report (para 17.15(j)). Without the expert's consent and the consent statement, quoted material falls under the stricter non-expert standard.

Industry data (HKEX Guide for New Listing Applicants, chapter 3.4):

Source of dataCautionary language limiting directors' and sponsor's responsibility?
Official government sources, documents or statementsMay be used
Expert reportsNot to be used: directors and sponsor must take reasonable care in selecting the expert
Commissioned or non-commissioned research reportsReasonable enquiries required; cautionary language only about practical difficulties in independent verification, with details given to the Exchange

The Industry Overview section discloses whether a research report was commissioned by the applicant, its connected persons or associates, or the sponsor; the fees paid; and the consultant's background and credentials. The sponsor tells the Exchange what due diligence it did on market position disclosure, including the consultant's methodology for market size and the top players.

1. The reporting accountants have issued the accountants' report. Must the sponsor redo their audit work?

No, unless it knows of matters raising concerns, which it must then follow up (para 17.7, Note 1).

2. An industry consultant's figures appear without its consent statement. Which standard applies to them?

The non-expert standard: without consent and the consent statement they are not an expert report (para 17.15(d), (j)).

3. May the listing document carry cautionary language on a commissioned research report?

Only about practical difficulties in independent verification, after reasonable enquiries, with details given to the Exchange (Guide 3.4).

4. Independent of whom must an expert be?

The listing applicant, its directors and its controlling shareholder(s) (para 17.7(a)).

Trap: thinking any professional's figures in the prospectus form an expert report. Consent and the consent statement are part of the definition.

Takeaway: Expert = profession gives the statement authority. Expert report needs consent. No disclaimers for expert reports; government data may carry them.

Practise this section · 3 questions (free account) →

MD&A: preparing the Financial Information section

Code of Conduct paragraph 17.8: a sponsor should, in conjunction with the listing applicant's management and its other advisers, prepare relevant, adequate and comprehensible MD&A that should:

  • •(a) avoid excessive or irrelevant disclosure that may overwhelm investors and obscure material matters and critical information;
  • •(b) focus on matters that materially affected historical financial performance or condition;
  • •(c) analyse and explain material fluctuations in financial items with specific and substantive reasons;
  • •(d) discuss material factors or events likely to affect future financial performance or condition; and
  • •(e) identify and discuss, from an investor's perspective, exceptional items or unusual accounting treatments that need further enquiry or disclosure, including by reference to comparable companies.

In the listing document the MD&A is the Financial Information section. HKEX's Guide for New Listing Applicants (chapter 3.11) sets the detail; Appendix D1A paragraph 32 requires an indebtedness statement as at the most recent practicable date, with commentary on liquidity, financial resources and capital structure.

Guide chapter 3.11 itemWhat good disclosure does
Key factors affecting resultsNames the events and factors driving historical and future results, specific to the applicant
Critical accounting policiesSays when and how revenue is recognised, not just 'on satisfaction of performance obligations'; states which permissible treatment was adopted and why, not all of them
Historical resultsExplains material movements with underlying reasons (not 'receivables fell because sales rose'); quantifies the impact of significant changes such as commodity prices; gives key ratios
Indebtedness and liquidityStatement as at a most recent practicable date no more than two calendar months before the Application Proof or final listing document

HKEX's Guide (chapter 3.1) gives a weak example: revenue 'has grown significantly ... given the favourable macroeconomic outlook'. It gives no insight; the applicant should give the underlying reasons and the factors for future growth.

Trap: an MD&A that restates the accountants' report or adds pages of general data. Paragraph 17.8 wants fewer, specific, explained points, including forward-looking factors.

Takeaway: Sponsor prepares MD&A with management: material, specific reasons, future factors, unusual items flagged. Indebtedness date within two calendar months.

Practise this section · 3 questions (free account) →

Traps that cost marks

  • Treating the Exchange's certificate as the registration. The Exchange authorises; the Registrar registers, and both must be done by the publication date.
  • Counting the 2 years back from the listing application or the accountants' report date instead of the date of issue, or listing ordinary-course trading contracts.
  • Thinking a forecast must look forward. A profit estimate for an expired, unaudited period is caught too, and needs both reports.

Now test it on exam-style questions

Sit a free, timed quick mock of exam-style questions. Try 5 with no sign-up, then the full mock with a free account.

Start the free mock

Full question bank and every mock: see passes

Keep studying HKSI Paper 15

HKSI Paper 15: exam format and practice

More on this topic