Lesson 1 of 5 · 16 min · free preview
The six forms of market misconduct and the two routes to enforcement
Hong Kong's Securities and Futures Ordinance (SFO) names six kinds of market misconduct and gives two ways to pursue them: civil proceedings before the Market Misconduct Tribunal (MMT), or a criminal prosecution. This lesson sets out the six forms in plain English with a desk-level example of each, shows who can be caught (including people who only help), and compares what each route can do to you. It ends with a fund manager who lost his profit and his access to the market without ever facing a criminal court. The law described is as at 15 Nov 2026. The SFC does not approve or endorse any CPT course, including this one: your firm decides whether it counts towards your CPT hours, and only time you actually spend counts.
Why this matters at the desk
Almost every manipulation or insider dealing scheme passes through a licensed corporation at some point. Orders go through your firm's systems, money and shares move through client accounts, and tips arrive in your chat apps. You are often the first person who can see that something is wrong. Sometimes you are also the person being asked to help.
The Code of Conduct builds this into its first two General Principles. You must act honestly, fairly, and with due skill, care and diligence, in the best interests of your clients and the integrity of the market (GP1 and GP2). Market integrity is part of your own job description, not something you can leave to compliance.
The six forms in plain English
Section 245 of the SFO defines market misconduct as six types of conduct. Each has its own section in Part XIII, the civil regime, and a matching criminal offence in Part XIV.
- Insider dealing (s.270; offence s.291). Dealing, or getting someone else to deal, in a listed company's securities or their derivatives while you know you hold inside information as a person connected with the company, a person planning a takeover of it, or someone who got the information from either, or passing that information on when you know or have reason to believe it will be used to deal. Example: a banker working on a privatisation loan buys the target's shares before the offer is announced.
- False trading (s.274; offence s.295). Doing anything with the intention of creating, or being reckless as to whether it creates, a false or misleading appearance of active trading, or of the market for or price of securities or futures. Example: churning a thin stock between accounts you control so it looks busy.
- Price rigging (s.275; offence s.296). Trades with no change in beneficial ownership that raise, lower, hold or move a price, or any fictitious or artificial transaction or device used with that intention or recklessly. Example: one person buying through one account and selling from another to print a higher last price.
- Disclosure of information about prohibited transactions (s.276; offence s.297). Spreading word that a stock's price will be pushed up, down, held or stabilised because of a prohibited transaction, where you or an associate took part in that transaction, or you or an associate receive or expect a benefit from spreading it. Example: telling clients a stock 'will be held at HK$1.20 this week' because your brother's group is supporting it.
- Disclosure of false or misleading information inducing transactions (s.277; offence s.298). Putting out information that is false or misleading as to a material fact, or misleading because it leaves a material fact out, and that is likely to induce dealing or move prices, where you know, are reckless or, for the civil regime, are negligent as to whether it is false or misleading. Example: a results announcement built on revenue that does not exist.
- Stock market manipulation (s.278; offence s.299). Two or more transactions that raise, lower, hold or stabilise a price, with the intention of inducing others to buy, sell or hold. Example: buying in steps to walk the price up while urging a chat group to buy.
Reach beyond Hong Kong, and fraud
The provisions are not limited to trades placed in Hong Kong. False trading, price rigging and stock market manipulation cover conduct in Hong Kong or elsewhere that affects Hong Kong markets, and also conduct in Hong Kong that affects markets outside Hong Kong (ss.274(1)-(2), 275(1)-(2), 278(1)-(2)). Getting someone to deal in the securities on a stock market outside Hong Kong that is not a recognised market, or tipping them to do so, is also insider dealing (s.270(2)).
Alongside the six, s.300 makes it a criminal offence, in any transaction involving securities, futures contracts or leveraged foreign exchange trading, to use a device, scheme or artifice with intent to defraud or deceive, or to engage in any act, practice or course of business that is fraudulent or deceptive. In a pending case about the alleged manipulation of a GEM-listed stock in 2018, five defendants were charged with offences including conspiracy to employ a scheme with intent to defraud or deceive in securities transactions under s.300; their District Court trial was due to start on 13 July 2026, and the charges are allegations until proved (25PR135).
Helping counts too
The definition in s.245 expressly includes attempting to engage in any of the six forms, and assisting, counselling or procuring another person to engage in them. The MMT can also identify a person who did not place the trades but assisted or connived with the person who did, knowing that the conduct constitutes or might constitute market misconduct (s.252(4)(c)). An officer of a corporation is caught if the corporation's misconduct happened with their consent or connivance (s.252(4)(b)).
For a dealer this is the uncomfortable part. Placing orders for a client whom you know is marking the close, splitting a client's matched orders so they do not look matched, or letting a friend trade unseen through an account you control, can make you a participant even if you make no money and the idea was not yours.
What you need to know or intend
Each form has its own mental element. The differences explain why some conduct ends up in the MMT and other conduct in a criminal court.
- Insider dealing needs you to know that the information is inside information. A tippee must also know the source is connected with the company and know or have reasonable cause to believe the source held it because of that connection (s.270(1)(e)).
- False trading is committed with intention or with recklessness as to the false or misleading effect (s.274(1)). You do not have to mean to mislead anyone.
- Wash trades and matched orders on the market are treated as done with that intention or recklessness unless they are off-market transactions (s.274(5)). It is then for the person to establish that their purposes did not include creating a false appearance (s.274(6)).
- Price rigging through trades with no change in beneficial ownership needs only the effect on the price. The person must then establish that none of their purposes was to create a false or misleading appearance of the price (s.275(1)(a) and (4)).
- Stock market manipulation needs the intention of inducing others to buy, sell or hold (s.278(1)).
- False or misleading information: knowledge, recklessness or negligence is enough for the MMT (s.277(1)), but the criminal offence needs knowledge or recklessness (s.298(1)).
Route one: the Market Misconduct Tribunal
If it appears to the SFC that market misconduct has or may have taken place, the SFC may start proceedings in the MMT (s.252(1)), but only with the consent of the Secretary for Justice (s.252A(1)). The Tribunal decides whether market misconduct took place, who engaged in it, and the amount of any profit gained or loss avoided (s.252(3)). It applies the standard of proof used in civil proceedings (s.252(7)) and must give a person a reasonable opportunity to be heard before identifying them (s.252(6)).
If it identifies you, it can make one or more of these orders (s.257(1)):
- disqualification from being a director of, or taking part in the management of, a listed or other specified corporation for up to 5 years without court leave;
- a 'cold shoulder' order banning you from dealing, directly or indirectly, in securities, futures contracts, leveraged foreign exchange contracts or collective investment schemes in Hong Kong for up to 5 years without court leave;
- a 'cease and desist' order not to engage in specified market misconduct again;
- disgorgement: paying the Government an amount up to the profit you gained or the loss you avoided;
- paying the Government's costs and the SFC's costs, including the costs of investigating you;
- a recommendation that any body which can discipline you as a member or regulatee take disciplinary action against you.
What the MMT cannot do, and what follows anyway
The MMT cannot imprison you or impose a criminal fine for market misconduct. That does not make it mild. Disgorgement can run to hundreds of millions of dollars, five years without access to Hong Kong markets would end most careers in this industry, and breaching a disqualification, cold shoulder or cease and desist order is itself an offence carrying, on conviction on indictment, a fine of HK$1 million and 2 years' imprisonment (s.257(10)).
Route two: criminal prosecution
Part XIV makes each of the six forms a criminal offence (ss.291 and 295 to 299). On conviction on indictment the maximum is a fine of HK$10 million and 10 years' imprisonment; on summary conviction, a fine of HK$1 million and 3 years (s.303(1)). The court can add the same kinds of orders the MMT uses: disqualification and cold shoulder orders of up to 5 years, a recommendation for disciplinary action, and an order to pay the Government up to the profit gained or loss avoided (s.303(2)).
Recent cases show two prosecutors at work. The SFC brings prosecutions in the Magistrates' Courts in its own name: in December 2025 a former vice president at a share registrar was jailed for two months and fined an amount equal to the loss he avoided, after pleading guilty to insider dealing (25PR209). The Department of Justice prosecutes cases in the higher courts, such as this District Court case: in February 2026 two men behind a social-media 'stock tips' securities fraud were jailed for 24 and 22 months (26PR20).
One route per conduct, and investor claims on top
The SFO stops the same conduct being pursued twice. Once criminal proceedings under Part XIV have started, MMT proceedings cannot be brought for the same conduct while the criminal case is pending, or once a fresh prosecution for that conduct would be barred (s.283). The same bar works the other way once MMT proceedings have started (s.307(1)).
Investors who lose money have their own statutory claim. A person who commits market misconduct is liable to pay damages to anyone who suffers a financial loss as a result, if it is fair, just and reasonable in the circumstances (s.281(1)-(2)). An MMT finding is admissible in that claim and is taken as proved unless the contrary is shown (s.281(7)-(8)). So a single finding can be followed by years of civil claims.
What happens to your licence
A market misconduct finding or conviction goes straight to whether you remain fit and proper. Licensed representatives have been jailed for false trading committed in their capacity as brokers (24PR90, Lesson 3). Others have been suspended for hidden personal dealing and for operating clients' accounts without authority, uncovered during ramp-and-dump investigations, without any finding that they manipulated the market themselves (26PR9, 26PR10, 25PR177, Lesson 4). The control breaches around market misconduct are disciplinary matters in their own right.
Enforcement case · 2024-07-03
Fund manager matched trades between his fund and his mother's account
- On 22 trading days in August and September 2014, a responsible officer who made the investment decisions for a hedge fund placed contemporaneous orders in two GEM-listed stocks through the fund's brokerage accounts and his mother's account, so that the opposing orders executed against each other.
- The MMT found the matched trades created a false or misleading appearance of active trading, or with respect to the price, and moved gains of HK$5.6 million into his mother's account at the fund's expense.
- The MMT ordered him to pay the Government HK$5,617,540, disqualified him from the management of any listed or unlisted corporation in Hong Kong for four years, imposed a four-year cold shoulder order (both effective 28 June 2024) and a cease and desist order, and ordered him to pay the SFC's investigation and legal costs and the costs of the proceedings.
- The proceedings were civil. There was no prison term, but the profit was stripped and he cannot deal in Hong Kong markets for four years without court leave.
What to do differently: Orders from accounts linked to the same person meeting each other is the textbook false trading pattern, and the MMT can take the profit and the market away from you without a criminal case. If you see a fund account and a family account trading against each other in a thin stock, escalate it, whoever is placing the orders.
Key points
- There are six forms: insider dealing, false trading, price rigging, disclosure of information about prohibited transactions, false or misleading information, and stock market manipulation (s.245).
- Attempting, assisting, counselling or procuring is covered, and knowing assistance can get you identified by the MMT (ss.245, 252(4)).
- The MMT route is civil: the SFC starts it with the Secretary for Justice's consent, and orders include 5-year bans, disgorgement and costs (ss.252, 252A, 257).
- The criminal route carries up to HK$10 million and 10 years on indictment (s.303).
- The same conduct cannot go down both routes (ss.283, 307), but investors can also sue for their losses (s.281).
Sources
- Securities and Futures Ordinance (Cap. 571), Sections 245, 252, 252A, 257, 270, 274, 275, 276, 277, 278, 281, 283, 291, 295-300, 303, 307 (version on e-Legislation as at 15 Nov 2026) (as at 2026-11-15)
- Code of Conduct for Persons Licensed by or Registered with the Securities and Futures Commission, General Principles 1 and 2 (thirty-third edition, January 2026, in force as at 15 Nov 2026) (as at 2026-11-15)
- SFC press release 24PR115, Press release 24PR115, 3 July 2024 (as at 2026-11-15)
- SFC press release 25PR135, Press release 25PR135, 29 August 2025 (as at 2026-11-15)
- SFC press release 25PR209, Press release 25PR209, 18 December 2025 (as at 2026-11-15)
- SFC press release 26PR20, Press release 26PR20, 9 February 2026 (as at 2026-11-15)
That was lesson 1 of 5.
This course includes an assessment and a completion record. The SFC does not approve or endorse CPT courses: your firm decides whether it counts toward your CPT, and CPT hours count only for time you actually spend.
See the full course