HKSI Prep

Lesson 1 of 3 · 15 min · free preview

Taking orders on messaging apps and personal phones

Clients want to reach you the way they reach everyone else: a WhatsApp message, a WeChat voice note, a call to your mobile at 9 pm. The SFC does not ban these channels outright, but it sets clear rules on how an order may be received, recorded and kept. This lesson covers the Code of Conduct rule on telephone and mobile orders, the SFC's 2018 circular on instant messaging, what changes when you work away from the office, and why taking orders 'off channel' on your own phone ends up as a disciplinary matter. These are the rules in force as at 15 Nov 2026. Your firm's own policy may be stricter, and where it is, the stricter policy is the one you follow. The SFC does not approve or endorse any CPT course, including this one: your firm decides whether it counts towards your CPT hours, and only time you actually spend counts.

Why the SFC cares where an order arrives

Every client order has to leave a trail: who gave it, when, and on what terms. In its circular of 4 May 2018 on receiving client orders through instant messaging, the SFC explained that complete and accurate records are an integral part of the audit trail. They give reliable evidence when a client disputes the particulars of an order, which protects both the client and the firm. They are also a supervisory tool. Compliance teams and the SFC use them to detect irregularities and potential malpractice, such as unauthorised trades or staff dealing ahead of clients.

An order that arrives on your personal phone and never reaches the firm's systems breaks that trail. Compliance cannot see it, cannot compare it with what was executed, and cannot defend you if the client later says 'I never asked for that'. That is why the rules below focus less on the technology and more on one question: does the firm have full control of the record.

The Code rule on telephone and mobile orders

Paragraph 3.9 of the Code of Conduct (thirty-third edition, January 2026) sets three basic requirements. First, a licensed or registered person should record and immediately time-stamp the particulars of instructions for agency orders and for internally generated orders, such as proprietary and staff account orders. Second, where clients give order instructions by telephone, the firm should use a telephone recording system and keep the recordings as part of its records for at least six months. Third, the firm should prohibit staff from receiving client order instructions through mobile phones when they are on the trading floor, in the trading room, or at the usual place of business where orders are received or business is conducted, and it should have a written policy that explains and enforces this.

The Notes to paragraph 3.9 add the part most representatives forget. The SFC strongly discourages the use of mobile phones for receiving client orders. Where an order is accepted on a mobile phone outside the trading floor or usual place of business, you should immediately call back to the firm's telephone recording system and record the time of receipt and the order details. Writing the details down by hand is a fallback only, for when the firm's recording system cannot be accessed.

For futures dealing on Hong Kong Futures Exchange, Schedule 4 to the Code applies a matching rule to trade confirmations: telephone confirmations go through the recording system, staff should not confirm executed trades on mobile phones on the trading floor, and a confirmation given by mobile outside the office should be followed at once by a call back to the recording system.

  • In the office: no client orders on your mobile phone. Ask the client to call the recorded line, or call the client back on it.
  • Outside the office: if you accept an order on your mobile, call the firm's recording system straight away and record the time of receipt and the order details.
  • Handwritten notes only when the recording system genuinely cannot be reached. Tell your supervisor or compliance why you had to use them.

Messaging apps: allowed only on the firm's terms

Instant messaging is not banned. The SFC's 2018 circular accepts that firms may receive orders through apps such as WhatsApp and WeChat, but only if the firm first understands the app's features and limitations, assesses the risks and puts specific controls in place. The SFC pointed out that most messaging providers give users no tools to save, retrieve or monitor messages. That is exactly the problem a firm has to solve before it lets staff take orders this way.

The circular sets expectations in five areas.

  • Centralised record keeping: order messages, and the messaging accounts and devices used to store them, should be centrally managed by the firm and stored so that they cannot be inappropriately modified or erased. All order messages should be kept for at least two years, in line with the Securities and Futures (Keeping of Records) Rules.
  • Security and reliability: the identity of a client who sends an order message should be authenticated. If in doubt, call the client at the registered phone number. Instructions received by message to transfer funds to a third-party account should be approved only on an exceptional basis, after verifying the client's identity through a different channel.
  • Compliance monitoring: order messages must be readily accessible for compliance and audit, and compared regularly with account activity to detect irregularities.
  • Internal policies: written policies, staff training, and monitoring so that orders received by message are executed promptly. Staff should be prohibited from making, sending or receiving electronic communications relating to client orders unless the firm has full control over the recording and retention of those messages.
  • Client awareness: clients should understand risks such as phishing, malware, account theft and impersonation before using messaging to place orders, and the terms for doing so should be agreed with them.

Applying the messaging rules to your own phone

The circular ends with a clear instruction: firms should prohibit staff from receiving orders through messaging apps if these requirements are not fully met, and the SFC will not hesitate to take regulatory action against firms that use messaging apps without enough controls.

For you, that gives a simple test. A messaging channel is acceptable for orders only if your firm has approved it and controls the account, the device and the record. Your personal WhatsApp on your personal phone almost never passes that test. Taking screenshots does not fix it, because the firm still does not control the record and you can still delete or edit what you keep.

Watch for requests that are riskier than a plain order. A client who uses messaging to ask you to pay money to a third party, change a registered phone number or email, or add an authorised person is the pattern fraudsters use when they impersonate a client or take over a client's account. Treat those requests as exceptional, and verify through a different channel using the contact details on the firm's records.

Working away from the office

Hybrid working did not suspend the order recording rules. In its circular on operational resilience and remote working (4 October 2021), the SFC said that where staff are allowed to trade off-premises, the firm's policies should ensure that remote staff use a recorded phone line to receive agency orders. Where there is no call recording at the remote location, staff should immediately call back to the firm's telephone recording system in the office to record the time of receipt and the order details. Where staff take client orders through messaging apps while working remotely, the 2018 messaging circular still applies in full.

Records also have a location rule. Under section 130 of the Securities and Futures Ordinance (SFO), a licensed corporation must not use any premises for keeping records or documents relating to its regulated activity without the SFC's prior written approval. The 2021 circular says that if remote staff temporarily keep required records at home, which is not approved premises, the firm should have procedures for the records to be sent back to approved premises as soon as practicable. The SFC also expects activity carried out through remote access to the firm's systems to be captured in the records those systems generate.

Why off-channel orders become a disciplinary issue

Representatives often see a quick WhatsApp order as good customer service. The SFC sees three problems. The order is not recorded and time-stamped as paragraph 3.9 requires. The firm cannot supervise it, so an unauthorised trade, an order placed ahead of the client or a disputed instruction can go unnoticed. And when the client disputes the trade, there is no reliable evidence of what was asked for.

Firms carry the policy duty, but you carry the conduct risk. The Code is written for 'a licensed or registered person', which includes you. A breach of the Code does not by itself make you liable in court, but the SFC will consider whether it reflects adversely on your fitness and properness (Code, para 1.4).

Using your own channel also creates practical traps. Messages on a personal phone can be lost, deleted or read by someone else. And a client who used your personal number once will use it again, including for requests you should never handle informally.

What to do on Monday morning

  • Read your firm's policy on mobile phones and messaging apps. Find out which channels are approved for orders, on which devices, and who controls the accounts.
  • If a client sends an order to your personal phone or app, do not execute it from there. Ask the client to call the recorded line, or call back on it yourself, and record the time and order details.
  • Never delete or edit messages that relate to client orders, on any device. If a client order reached you through an unapproved channel, tell compliance.
  • Tell regular clients, through an approved channel, how they should place orders with you, and keep that message on record.
  • If you work remotely, check how your firm wants you to record orders, and return any paper records to the office as soon as practicable.

Enforcement case · 2023-09-18

Broker fined over missing order records and mobile phone orders

  • The SFC reprimanded and fined Chee Tak Securities Limited, a Type 1 broker, $2 million for internal control failures between July 2018 and March 2020, and suspended its responsible officer for 10 months.
  • The firm admitted it had no written manual, policy or procedure on recording order instructions. A sample review found no time-stamped order records for certain trades.
  • It had a telephone recording system, but did not check phone orders against recordings and did not require account executives to call back to the recording system to record orders received on mobile phones outside the trading floor.
  • It also did not prohibit staff from receiving client orders on mobile phones while on the trading floor.
  • The SFC said telephone recording lets a firm establish a client's instruction in a dispute and also works as a tool to prevent or detect irregular or fraudulent activity. The same investigation found weak controls over cross trades between an account executive and a client.

What to do differently: Order recording rules are not paperwork for its own sake. In this case, missing order records sat alongside staff-client cross trades that the firm failed to monitor. Use the recorded line, call back when you take a mobile order outside the office, and assume that any order you cannot evidence will be read against you.

Source: SFC press release 23PR102, 18 Sep 2023

Key points

  • Orders must be recorded and time-stamped immediately; telephone orders go through the recording system and recordings are kept for at least six months.
  • No client orders on mobile phones on the trading floor or at your usual place of business; outside it, call back to the recording system at once and record the time and details.
  • Messaging apps are allowed for orders only if the firm controls the account, device and record, and keeps order messages for at least two years in a form that cannot be altered.
  • Instructions by message to pay a third party should be approved only exceptionally, after verifying the client through a different channel.
  • Remote working does not change the rules: use a recorded line or call back, and return records kept at home to approved premises as soon as practicable.

Sources

That was lesson 1 of 3.

This course includes an assessment and a completion record. The SFC does not approve or endorse CPT courses: your firm decides whether it counts toward your CPT, and CPT hours count only for time you actually spend.

See the full course